How to manage tensions when collaborating with your competitors?
Coopetition, a form of collective strategy where two or more competitors collaborate, can lead to otcomes, including innovation, that each company cannot achieve alone. Yet such a strategy creates persistent tensions between collaborative and competitive dynamics. Successfully navigating these tensions requires separate leadership responses at different levels.However, when tensions escalate, joint management across levels within companies is crucial.
This is a summary of the article “Sustaining collective strategy through cross-level leadership: Microdynamics of managing paradoxical tensions in coopetition projects”, by Synnøve Nesse, published in the highly ranked scientific journal “Strategic Organization”.
Read the full scientific article here
Companies increasingly collaborate with competitors to solve shared challenges and create new opportunities for better results, innovation and growth. Different companies may join using artificial intelligence across pooled data, developing common technology, establishing new infrastructure or to address problems that are simply too large for one company to solve alone. There is, however, an inherent tension in collaborating with competitors. Companies cooperate to create value while continuing to compete over who captures that value.
This combination of cooperation and competition, often called coopetition, can become particularly challenging in innovation projects. Companies need to share knowledge and resources to make progress while simultaneously protecting commercially sensitive information, intellectual property and their own competitive positions.
How do leaders manage these tensions and enable collective strategizing between competitors to continue over time? Based on five years of research into innovation projects involving competing firms, an important insight emerges. Different levels of leadership in companies succeeding to coopete, manage these tensions separately using distinct responses to tensions. Yet, crucially – they engage in cross-level interplay when tensions escalate to sustain the collective strategic effort.
Competitive tensions persist even when companies agree to collaborate
The study has examined six collaborative projects, involving companies in banking, insurance, aquaculture, seafood, media and subsea technology. The specific projects included an interbank API platform, AI-driven fraud detection, a big-data Ai-driven platform for aquaculture and the development of cloud and subsea technologies.
The analysis of leadership across levels within companies draws on 77 interviews with top managers, project managers and cluster leaders, complemented by observations and documents collected over five years.
Despite the diversity of the projects, a common pattern emerged, where even when companies had agreed to collaborate, the underlying tension between cooperation and competition persisted throughout the projects. Concerns arose over sensitive data, unequal contributions of resources, the distribution of benefits, trust between partners and the potential loss of competitive advantage.
These tensions were an inherent feature of working with competitors that needed to be managed. The key managerial challenge, therefore, is not to eliminate tensions, but to prevent escalating tensions from becoming destructive, not just to the specific project, but to the collective strategic initiative.
Different leadership roles serve different purposes
An key finding is that top managers and project managers did not respond to these tensions in the same manner, and that their responses varied both cognitively (their mindset) and emotionally.
When tensions remain manageable, top managers tend to respond to tensions through a paradoxical mindset. They acknowledge both sides of the relationship at the same time: the company needs to collaborate but also needs to protect its own interests. They would also be aware of ambivalence emerging from project managers, to be able to gauge if negative emotions should be considered a sign of emerging competitive disadvantages. Top managers therefore remain alert to both opportunities and competitive risks.
Project managers respond differently when tensions remain manageable, displaying a paradox-separating mindset. Their focus was on making collaboration work. Rather than continuously focusing on the competitive dimension, they tend to concentrate on practical problems, technical solutions and project progress. Competitive concerns are temporarily pushed into the background.
This distinction is important. Managing a coopetition strategy requires, on the one hand, to keep the project moving, and on the other to keep a keen eye on the strategic implications for the company.
Changing leadership responses as tensions escalate
Role-differentiated responses work as long as tensions are manageable. Tensions may however escalate when concerns over issues such as trust, resource commitments, competitive exposure or unequal benefits become too significant to be handled within the project.
At these critical points, successful projects show another pattern: project managers elevate the issue to senior management. Top managers then become more actively involved with tensions. They assess whether concerns are justified, clarify disagreements and consider the broader strategic interests of the firm. Together with project managers, they can adjust expectations, commitments, resources or the terms of participation. Nesse describes this as recalibrating the participation in the project.
The aquaculture project illustrates the process. Based on concerns perceived by the project manager one company gradually became concerned that it was contributing a disproportionate share of the technical resources to a common data platform. Rather than abandoning the collaboration, the project manager and top manager reduced part of its resource commitment while maintaining its relationships and involvement in the broader initiative. When contributions later became more balanced and the platform improved, the company increased its involvement again.
The important point is that stepping back did not necessarily mean ending their participation in the coopetitive project. Adjusting the relationship allowed the company to remain part of it.
Relations and progress – enabling cooperation
The study also challenges a narrow understanding of what successful coopetitive projects are.
The projects, through repeated recalibrations from managing emerging tensions, generated learning, technological progress, and strengthened relationships. This made companies better equipped to work together on multiple collective strategic initiatives.
The insurance case is particularly illustrative. Competing companies collaborated on a machine-learning solution for fraud detection using shared data. A cluster leader observed that the most novel aspect was not simply the machine-learning model, but the ability of competing companies to share data and develop common infrastructure, generating learning, innovation progress and relationships that they could build on in subsequent shared initiatives.
For managers working with collective strategies across firms developing AI tools and systems, digital platforms or data ecosystems, this is a key take away. Technological innovation alone does not determine whether coopetition succeeds. The companies involved also develop capabilities that allow them to pursue collective strategic initiatives, while continuing to experience tensions in coopetitive projects.
What should managers take away?
- First, expect tensions rather than treating them as exceptions. Cooperation between competitors does not remove conflicts of interest. Questions about data, knowledge, resources, ownership and the distribution of benefits are likely to remain throughout the collaboration.
- Second, recognize that different leadership levels have different roles in managing tensions. Project managers can create momentum by focusing on solving problems and making the collaboration work. Senior leaders need to retain a broader perspective, balancing the benefits of collaboration against the company's strategic and competitive interests.
- Third, when tensions escalate, their joint efforts to resolve tensions it is key to achieve recalibration and continued participation. When tensions rise regarding competitive issues, project managers and senior leaders need to work together jointly. This does not necessarily resolve the underlying paradox, but serves to recalibrate engagement in the project sufficiently for the parties to continue working together.
For organizations increasingly dependent on ecosystems, partnerships, common platforms and shared data, this capability may become increasingly important.
Successful collaboration with competitors is not about removing the tension between cooperation and competition. It is about learning how to manage that tension well enough to keep creating value together.
Read the full scientific article here
Source:
Synnøve Nesse, “Sustaining collective strategy through cross-level leadership: Microdynamics of managing paradoxical tensions in coopetition projects,” Strategic Organization (2026).