For cluster managers and policymakers, the message is quite practical. Do not only look at the number of members, events or meetings. Also look at the connections.
Ivan Belik
Innovation clusters are built on a simple idea: bring relevant companies and institutions closer together, create meeting places, and collaboration will follow. This sounds reasonable. But membership alone does not tell us how collaboration actually happens.
In our recent research, together with Ivan Belik, Eirik Sjåholm Knudsen, Kari Sofie Mysen Conradsen and Max Hartvig-Larsen, we studied NCE Finance Innovation and the wider Norwegian fintech ecosystem. We used social network analysis to map how organizations are connected through relationships with innovation partners, suppliers, customers, competitors and financing partners. The combined network contained 453 actors and 810 unique ties.
First, the formal cluster was much more tightly connected than the wider ecosystem. Its network density was 12.8%, compared with 0.7% in the broader organic network. Information also had fewer steps to travel between actors, and the cluster contained many more tightly connected subgroups.
In other words, the cluster appears to do something important: it creates relational infrastructure that can make interaction and information exchange easier.
But that is only part of the story.
When cluster members freely listed their most important relationships, many of those relationships were with organizations outside the formal cluster. This is potentially valuable. Innovation does not stop at the membership boundary. A strong cluster can combine close internal relationships with external connections that bring in new knowledge and perspectives.
For cluster managers and policymakers, the message is quite practical. Do not only look at the number of members, events or meetings. Also look at the connections.
Ivan Belik
We also found that organizations occupy different positions within the cluster network. A smaller number of organizations are highly connected and play important bridging roles, while others have fewer direct connections. Traditional financial institutions, consultancies and technology developers were among the more central actors, while fintech start-ups had fewer direct connections on average.
Interestingly, actors with more central network positions also tended to report greater innovation-related benefits from cluster membership. This is an association rather than evidence of causality, but it suggests that how organizations engage in the network may matter alongside formal membership itself.
For cluster managers and policymakers, the message is quite practical. Do not only look at the number of members, events or meetings. Also look at the connections.
Which organizations connect different parts of the network? Where could useful new relationships be created? And how can knowledge coming from outside the cluster be shared more broadly inside it?
The goal is not to connect everyone to everyone. Maintaining relationships takes time and resources.
The more important task is to create the right connections.
Sometimes the strength of a cluster is not visible in its member list.
It is visible in the relationships between them.